19. "Is This It?"- The Strokes

For as long as the other albums on this list have been in my life, this one has only recently entered it. The Strokes were always a band “just outside my radar.” In other words, I listened to and greatly enjoyed bands and artists that sounded like them but I never made the jump to listen to them myself, always knowing that I would most likely highly enjoy them. Over the years, I had heard “Reptilla.” In fact I first came across it at a party in 8^th grade. I wasn’t ready.

In my study of music, I had gathered a sense of the Strokes and the space they occupy as a band. Very similar to The White Stripes, they were heralded as pioneers ahead of their time sonically by borrowing from sounds of the past. Both bands standing out from the rest of the musical landscape of the time and both primarily enjoyed by critics and college students.

This past winter, being slightly past the age of a college student and fancying myself a music critic, I decided it was time to give this highly praised debut a try. I was impressed from the start. I love the gumption to begin an album and a career with the phrase “Is this it?” Instead of an all out showcase of skill and talent that is loud and attention grabbing, Julian and crew are subdued and almost passive. If you as a listener chose to enter in, that’s your call and they will carry on either way. As the last track declares “Take It or Leave It” Needless to say, I walked right in.

I found a collection of songs that are essentially reflections and brief stories from a time in life that I could at last relate to: early adulthood. I know that I would not have been able to relate the songs when I was in high school or even early on in college. Now, on the cusp of 24, I had my share of “Last Night”s so to speak. I also feel like I probably would have looked for more musically from the band when I was younger. The deliberate choice to do less would have been lost on me. I would not have been able to appreciate the tradition that the band enters into with this album.

In so many ways, “Someday” and “Last Night” are instant classics. Both quick and equipped with a catchy chorus fun to both sing and shout, they have infiltrated pop culture and do serve as landmarks to the large album overall. It is hard not to tap along to them with your feet.

Having gotten into this album almost fifteen years after its release, I able to enjoy it in context of the bigger picture. Like I wrote, I can see them standing on the shoulders of the Ramones. I can also hear bands like Rooney and The Bravery taking notes and preparing for their careers to start. It does not have to be this collection of songs serving as contrast to its contemporaries. It just has to sound good. 

20. "The Unforgettable Fire"- U2

I cannot remember exactly when I started listening to this album. Sure, I had heard of U2. In fact, the purchase of “U218 Singles” in 10^th grade was a big moment musically in high school. I listened to that album constantly, enjoying the pop sensibility exercised by the band throughout their career. I heard each track as a testament to the band’s ability to make great music no matter the decade.

I imagine that I first “ripped” this album from a copy belonging to a library. I think it occurred around 2010. I can remember listening to it during the summer of 2011, but I do not know if it started then. I guess along the way I  had absorbed the history of the album and the album's place in the discography of the band and became curious. I pieced together that the album followed three loud albums and that it came right before the big, breakout of “Joshua Tree.” I am sure I liked the idea that possibly it could have been a forgotten album, or at the very least, an overlooked one. For that quality is what I love about a lot of the music from the 80’s that I enjoy i.e. The Smiths and The Replacements.

At some point, it must have clicked, and I found myself drawn in by the opening drums and shimmering guitar of “A Sort of Homecoming.” A track full in instrumentation and Bono vocal range, it runs into the better known “Pride (In The Name ofLove)", which I first enjoyed as a part of the compilation and now hear in the context of the other U.S. themed tracks on the album. Throughout the album are numerous references to recent (at the time) American history and staples of the “American Dream.” Coming from the perspective of an Irish Band in the 80’s, I just find it fascinating that they found it so fascinating.

“Wire” is just fun. There are loud, almost industrial sounds on it. The song seems to pick up pace and slow down at moments. I love the opening lyric “Innocent, and in a sense I am.” I do not use that nearly enough but it shows that Bono can sing and wink at the same time. This playfulness would fully come out during the “Achtung Baby” era. Also, some of the grunts toward the end of the song foreshadow “Bullet The Blue Sky” on the album to come.

The song that is my absolute favorite is the title track. I have taken many a walk at night, during twilight to it, and gotten lost in the sky. I just think the playing on it is so beautiful. It is the kind of performance where I do not feel like I have the musical knowledge to talk about it properly. I won’t pretend to. I can only say that it remains one of my favorite things ever. I will listen to it independent of the album. Each time, the listening experience brings me peace. I feel a swelling of joy. It is something very special to me. I always try to put it on a mix CD or tell a friend about it.

From there on out and the second half of the album especially, the band shows off their ability to be artistically ambient. In many ways, the mood of the title track contains. It is a talent that I feel often is not highlighted enough when it comes to the band. Sure, folks marvel at their beginning, watch as they rise as a band in the late 80’s, only having to then reinvent themselves in the 90’s, redefine touring forever, and then permanently take their place in the hierarchy of modern music. 

For me, this is the period of U2 I feel I would have enjoyed the most if I were alive at the time. I find myself today drawn to a lot of music that sounds very similar. I think a lot of today’s alternative and college rock draws from this album, both consciously and unconsciously.

Ultimately, a lot this album remains a mystery for me. Despite my best attempts, I can never know what it was like to be a fan at the time. I have the knowledge of all that would come next, the full story, not just what happened up until this moment. Also, like I said, I find a lot of the sounds a mystery. I am simply left to allow them to have an affect on me. Much of Bono's singing is also hard to figure out.  And what is up with that album cover? Where does that place exist on Earth? 

All of this is why I come back each time. I am able to engage with the mystery once more, maybe solve some of it, but at the very least, have an enjoyable listening experience.